Wednesday, 31 August 2022

Russia: Mikhail Gorbachev changed history, but was wrong about ties to West

Mikhail Gorbachev - the last Soviet leader, who died on Tuesday - had a "huge impact on the course of history", Russia's President Vladimir Putin says.


By Merlyn Thomas
BBC News  https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-62735271

Published 2 hours ago
31 August 2022
MIKHAEL GORBATCHEVIMAGE SOURCE,GETTY IMAGES
Image caption,
Mikhail Gorbachev was widely acclaimed in the West, but reviled by many at home

Mikhail Gorbachev - the last Soviet leader, who died on Tuesday - had a "huge impact on the course of history", Russia's President Vladimir Putin says.

He had understood reforms were necessary, Mr Putin said - while the head of the UN, António Guterres, hailed a "tireless advocate for peace".

Mr Putin's spokesman, however, said Mr Gorbachev had been wrong to believe in "eternal romance" with the West.

Mr Gorbachev took power in 1985, before the Soviet Union collapsed by 1991.

He introduced reforms, but was unable to prevent the slow collapse of the union - and many Russians blamed him for the years of turmoil that ensued.

In his message, President Putin said: "He deeply understood that reforms were necessary, he strove to offer his own solutions to urgent problems."

Mr Putin and Mr Gorbachev had a strained relationship - their last meeting reportedly in 2006.

Most recently, Mr Gorbachev was said to have been unhappy with Mr Putin's decision to invade Ukraine, even though he had supported the annexation of Crimea in 2014.

The Russian leader's spokesman, Dmitry Peskov, said Mr Gorbachev had "sincerely wanted to believe that the Cold War would end, and that it would usher in a period of eternal romance between a new Soviet Union and the world, the West. This romanticism turned out to be wrong".

Mr Peskov then berated Western countries that have opposed the invasion of Ukraine, imposed crippling sanctions on Russia, and provided weapons to Kyiv.

In his tribute, UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson said he admired Mr Gorbachev's courage and integrity, adding: "In a time of Putin's aggression in Ukraine, his tireless commitment to opening up Soviet society remains an example to us all."

US President Joe Biden called him a "rare leader", while UN Secretary General António Guterres said: "The world has lost a towering global leader, committed multilateralist, and tireless advocate for peace."

The hospital in Moscow where Mr Gorbachev died said he had been suffering from a long and serious illness.

In recent years, his health had been in decline and he had been in and out of hospital. In June, international media reported that he was suffering from a kidney ailment, though his cause of death has not been announced.

He will be buried in Moscow's Novodevichy cemetery, the resting place of many prominent Russians. It is not clear whether he will receive a state funeral.

Mr Gorbachev became general secretary of the Soviet Communist Party, and de facto leader of the country, in 1985.

At the time, he was 54 - the youngest member of the ruling council known as the Politburo, and was seen as a breath of fresh air after several ageing leaders. His predecessor, Konstantin Chernenko, had died aged 73 after just over a year in office.

Few leaders have had such a profound effect on the global order, but Mr Gorbachev did not come to power seeking to end the Soviet grip over eastern Europe. Rather, he hoped to revitalise its society.

The Soviet economy had been struggling for years to keep up with the US and his policy of perestroika sought to introduce some market-like reforms to the state run system.

Internationally he reached arms control deals with the US, refused to intervene when eastern European nations rose up against their Communist rulers, and ended the bloody Soviet war in Afghanistan that had raged since 1979.

Meanwhile, his policy of glasnost, or openness, allowed people to criticise the government in a way which had been previously unthinkable.

But it also unleashed nationalist sentiments in many parts of the Soviet Union which eventually undermined its stability and hastened its collapse.

In 1991, after a shambolically organised coup by communist hardliners failed, Mr Gorbachev agreed to dissolve the Soviet Union and left office.

 

Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev signing the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty in 1987


He is seen in the West as an architect of reform who created the conditions for the end of the Cold War in 1991 - a time of deep tensions between the Soviet Union and Western nations.

He was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 1990 "for the leading role he played in the radical changes in East-West relations".

But in the new Russia that emerged after 1991, he was on the fringes of politics, focusing on educational and humanitarian projects.

Mr Gorbachev made one ill-fated attempt to return to political life in 1996, receiving just 0.5% of the vote in presidential elections.

Henry Kissinger, who served as US Secretary of State under President Richard Nixon, told the BBC's Newsnight programme that Mr Gorbachev would be "remembered in history as a man who started historic transformations that were to the benefit of mankind and to the Russian people".


Media caption,

Watch: Henry Kissinger pays tribute to Mikahil Gorbachev

Vladimir Rogov, a Russian-appointed official in occupied Ukraine, said Mr Gorbachev had "deliberately led the [Soviet] Union to its demise" and called him a traitor.

What ordinary Russians thought of him was perhaps encapsulated in a Pizza Hut advertisement - designed for the US market - that he took part in 1997.

In the ad, diners debate the chaos unleashed - or the opportunities created - by the end of the union, before toasting him.


https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-62735271

Goodbye Mr. Perestroika: World's Front Pages Bid Adieu To Mikhail Gorbachev

 International newspapers pay homage to the last of the USSR leaders.



https://worldcrunch.com/gorbachev-death


Former Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev waves at a Russian book launch event in 2015.


Mikhail Gorbachev, the eighth and final leader of the Soviet Union, died Tuesday from a long illness at the Moscow Central Clinical Hospital in Moscow, at age 91. His six years at the head of the USSR, from 1985 to 1991, were notably marked by his role in bringing the Cold War to an end, changing the course of world history.

Born in 1931 in a poor peasant family of Russian and Ukrainian heritage in Privolnoye, Gorbachev grew up in the aftermath of the Soviet famine of 1932–1933 and under the rule of Joseph Stalin. After rising through the ranks of the Communist party, Gorbachev’s reforms ushered in a period of perestroika (“restructuring”) and glasnost (“openness”), contributing to the mostly peaceful end to the Cold War and eventually, the fall of the USSR.

Tributes have been pouring in from politicians and leaders across the world: UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres called Gorbachev "a one-of-a-kind statesman" while U.S. President Joe Biden paid tribute to a "rare leader" who worked for a better future.

At the same time, international commentators noted that his death came amid Russia’s current war against Ukraine, and renewed dangers of global conflict and nuclear perils, putting a new dark twist to his “ambivalent legacy,” as French daily Le Monde puts it.

Here’s how international outlets featured his passing on their front pages:


U.S. - The Washington Post


The Washington Post




Brazil - Estadao


"The last leader of the Soviet Union dies at 91" — 
Estadao




Switzerland - Neue Zürcher Zeitung


“Mikhail Gorbachev dies at 91” — 
Neue Zürcher Zeitung



Spain - ABC

“Goodbye mister perestroika” — ABC



Italy - Corriere Della Sera


“Farewell Gorbachev who changed the world”— 
Corriere Della Sera



UK - The Guardian


The Guardian


Austria - Kleine Zeitung


"This man wrote the history of the world" — 
Kleine Zeitung


Peru - El Comercio

“Mikhail Gorbachev, leader of the USSR who ended the Cold War, dies” — El Comercio



Ireland - Irish Independent


Germany - Frankfurter Allgemeine


“Mikhail Gorbachev dies” — 
Frankfurter Allgemeine



Argentina - Clarin


"Mikhail Gorbachev, the leader who changed the world map” — 
Clarin




Canada - Toronto Star



https://worldcrunch.com/gorbachev-death

Opinion: Mikhail Gorbachev failed, and made the world a better place

 Many countries and people around the world owe their freedom to Mikhail Gorbachev, the last Soviet leader. His present-day successor, Vladimir Putin, could not be more different, says DW's Miodrag Soric.

  • Date 31.08.2022
  • Author Miodrag Soric

https://www.dw.com/en/opinion-mikhail-gorbachev-failed-and-made-the-world-a-better-place/a-62985901

A cartoon of Gorbachev walking through a hole in the Berlin Wall, with a pickax over his shoulder

Gorbachev helped end Cold War divisions in Europe

The Communist utopia never became reality — neither through kind words and promises, nor through mass executions and gulags.

In 1985, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union undertook one last effort to preserve its empire. The Soviet Union's relatively young leader at the time, Mikhail Gorbachev, was meant to bridge a growing gap and catch up with the West. But, just like all his predecessors, he floundered.

His failure didn't just end the Cold War. By loosening the shackles of repression that held the Communist empire together, he gave millions of people their freedom back and with it their dignity — among them Russians, Ukrainians and other people in the Soviet Union. 

They regained their national identities as Russians, Georgians, Armenians, Latvians and so on, becoming citizens with civil rights. They were no longer expected to think of themselves as the proletariat standing in front of empty supermarket shelves and at the same time, pretending to live in some kind of paradise.

'A common European home'

It's tragic that Gorbachev has passed away now, of all times. After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, the people of the Baltic states — Poles, Czechs, Slovaks, East Germans, Romanians and others — joined what Gorbachev once called the "common European home."

A middle-aged man wearing a dark suit and tie, and glasses with half a rim

Miodrag Soric is chief correspondent for DW

But his own Russian compatriots still cannot decide to do the same. Russia is a belated nation. Even worse, the current Kremlin leader, Vladimir Putin, also wants to prevent Ukrainians and Belarusians from taking the path to freedom and democracy. 

Putin wants a return to pathos, utopia and slavery. He wants people to serve the state, not vice versa, like in Communist times. As in the Communist dictatorship, any public dissent is dangerous in today's Russia, where citizens are lied to via the state-controlled media. Just like the members of the erstwhile Politburo, Putin suffers from the delusion that Moscow is surrounded by enemies.  As in the time of Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev, today's Nomenklatura is lining its pockets at the public's expense, with corruption and mismanagement rife.

Gorbachev promoted transparency by opening the Soviet archives so that Russians could see for themselves how many millions of their own people Stalin and Lenin had killed for no reason. Putin did the opposite: Closing the archives, censoring history books, reintroducing the state's dogma of the infallibility, and resorting to lies to promote the patriotic education of the masses.  

Putin, a political dinosaur

During his time, Gorbachev withdrew troops from the unwinnable Afghanistan war. Putin, on the other hand, has dispatched forces in a "special military operation" to fight non-existent fascism in Ukraine. Putin is a political dinosaur, inspired by 19th century ideas. He is a leader who fights to set up global "spheres of interest" because he is unable to modernize Russia's economy and infrastructure.

He does not understand that young Russians today will choose material prosperity — like the latest iPhone — over national greatness (whatever that is). This is evident from the hundreds of thousands of highly educated Russians who have left the country since the invasion of Ukraine began in February.

Granted, Gorbachev was a party functionary with little economic expertise. East Germany's command economy, supposedly one of the most advanced systems around, was impossible to reform, as became clear after 1990. Most likely any Kremlin leader would have failed trying to quickly reform Moscow's planned economy.

Putin's alleged economic achievements 20 years ago were due entirely to high commodity prices. Or are there any products that Russia has developed and produces that are in demand anywhere in the world — apart from weapons? 

Language of the pariah

Gorbachev secured a place in the history books. No other politician changed the world for the better in the second half of the 20th century as he did. Millions of people across the world started learning the Russian language because of Gorbachev, this new, humane politician.

Putin, in contrast, has turned Russian into the language of the pariah. Even many Ukrainians now avoid speaking it. And in the West, cultural managers feel they need to justify themselves for putting on a Tchaikovsky ballet, or a Dostoevsky reading, and so stage something else instead.

Yes, Gorbachev's life was sometimes tragic, he failed all too often. But his intention was to change the world for the better. At least he tried.

This article was originally published in German

  • Date 31.08.2022
  • Author Miodrag Soric




https://www.dw.com/en/opinion-mikhail-gorbachev-failed-and-made-the-world-a-better-place/a-62985901